Ace the 2025 CBP Border Patrol Agent Exam – Patrol Your Way to Success!

The appropriate response to an alien who chooses not to relinquish their Alien Registration Card involves issuing a Notice to Appear before an Immigration Judge. This action is necessary because the refusal to surrender the Alien Registration Card may indicate a potential issue with the alien's status or compliance with immigration requirements.

Issuing a Notice to Appear formally initiates the legal process to address the circumstances surrounding the alien's residency and any violations that may have occurred. This notice not only informs the alien of their obligation to appear but also allows for a due process hearing where the immigration judge can evaluate the case on its merits.

This approach ensures that all appropriate legal protocols are followed, allowing the immigration system to function effectively and fairly. Other options, such as issuing a temporary residence permit or ignoring the decision, would not adequately address the legal implications of the alien's choice regarding their registration card. A Notice of Transfer typically pertains to different procedural contexts and would not be relevant in this scenario.